At John Muir Elementary School in San Francisco, Ryan Lawler teaches Kindergarten and Sara Liebert teaches fourth grade. They are part of the school’s Lesson Study team, and for public lessons, they decided to use *One Is a Snail, Ten Is a Crab* with their classes. They were familiar with the lesson I described in my earlier blog post about using the book with second graders, and they saw possibilities for their classes.

**About the Book
**The subtitle of the book appears on the book’s cover:

*A Counting by Feet Book*. Set at the beach, the book counts by groups of feet:

**1** is a snail (because a snail touches the sand on the beach at only one spot, with its belly)

**2** is a person (arrows in the illustration point to a boy’s two feet)

**3** is a person and a snail (arrows point to the three feet)

**4** is a dog (arrows again here for the feet, and in all the illustrations that follow)

**5** is a dog and a snail

**6** is an insect

**7** is an insect and a snail

**8** is a spider

**9** is a spider and a snail

**10** is a crab (including its front two feet that are also claws)

The book then continues by multiples of 10 up to 100, which the illustration shows as 10 crabs and also as 100 snails.

**A Kindergarten Lesson
**Before the lesson, Ryan duplicated small cut-outs of the pictures in the book of the snail, person, dog, insect, and spider. He put the cut-outs of the creatures in five separate small plastic tubs, and prepared a set of tubs for each table group.

Ryan gathered his students on the carpet and introduced the book, *One Is a Snail, Ten Is a Crab*. He read aloud until the book introduced the number 5 as a dog (4 feet) and a snail (1 foot). He stopped and asked, “Is there another way we can show five feet?” Students made suggestions—five snails, and two people and one snail. For each, Ryan showed the corresponding cut-outs and asked, “How do we know there are five feet?” He gave the students sentence frames for explaining: *I made five by . . . I know it is five because . . .*

Ryan continued reading the book to the number 10, which the book illustrates with a crab. Ryan had intended to model for the students another way to show ten feet using other animals in the book, but Jabari raised his hand and volunteered, “You could show 10 with a spider and two snails.” Ryan followed Jabari’s lead, using the cut-outs to demonstrate Jabari’s idea concretely. He asked, “How do we know there are ten feet?” He reminded Jabari to use the sentence frames: *I made ten by . . . I know it is ten because . . .*

Ryan then explained to the class what they were going to do at their tables individually. He gave each child a worksheet he had prepared with a crab on it and a blank space for gluing down cut-outs.

He reminded them that a crab has ten feet and told them they were to paste down cut-outs to show 10 feet in another way. When they were done, they were to bring their paper to the carpet and explain what they had done to another student in the “give one, get one” protocol and using the sentence frames he had introduced.

He then had students return to their tables to make 10 in a different way. Ryan planned to use the students’ papers of cut-outs later to connect their concrete experience to writing addition expressions.

__A Follow-Up Activity
__A few days later, Ryan asked the children to do the assignment again. This time he gave them the constraint that they could use only one or two snails when showing 10 feet. In an email to me, Ryan wrote that this pushed a lot of the children, especially those who had chosen one animal and then pasted snails, one by one, counting each time until they had 10 feet altogether. Now, after selecting an animal, they’d think about how many more they needed to make 10.

__Note__: To make the cut-outs, Ryan took photos of the animals in the book with his phone, organized them into a Word document table, printed them, then duplicated them and cut them out. Pictures of the animals are also available online.

**A Fourth Grade Lesson
**Sara had read

*One Is a Snail, Ten Is a Crab*to her class earlier in the school year, and the students had written riddles for numbers up to 20, similar to the lesson I described in my earlier blog. To prepare for this lesson, Sara posted a list of the creatures in the book and how many feet each had.

**Snail 1 foot
**

**Person 2 feet**

**Dog 4 feet**

**Insect 6 feet**

**Spider 8 feet**

**Crab 10 feet**Sara reminded the students that the book represented the number 50 in two different ways and asked if anyone could remember how.

Most of the students recalled that the book showed 50 as five crabs. Sara wrote two equations on the board:

*5 crabs = 50
*

*10 + 10 + 10 + 10 + 10 = 50*

Jayden said he could use multiplication and write “five times ten.” He preempted Sara’s plan to introduce this as well. Sara added to the board:

*5 x 10 = 50*

A few students remembered the other way the book had illustrated 50, and again Sara wrote first an equation using the creatures from the book, then an equation using addition, and then an equation also using multiplication. She used parentheses, explaining to the students that it was clarifying punctuation, as they had learned before, but not essential.

*1 crab + 10 dogs = 50
*

*10 + 4 + 4 + 4 + 4 + 4 + 4 + 4 + 4 + 4 + 4 = 50*

*10 + (10 x 4) = 50*

Sara then explained the task, “Now you are going to work independently to come up with other ways to show 50 feet. I’m going to give you five minutes to work by yourselves and see if you can come up with at least two different ways. Then you’ll share your thinking with your partner, check each other’s ideas, and see if you can come up with any other ways.”

The students got to work. The next day, Sara posted their solutions and had a gallery walk so that students could see the different ways they found.

**About the John Muir Lesson Study Project
**An ongoing professional development programs in the San Francisco Unified School District (SFUSD) is the Lesson Study Project, and John Muir Elementary School is one of the schools participating in the project. The program is being conducted in cooperation with the Lesson Study Group at Mills College in Oakland, California, led by Catherine Lewis. The district description of the project states: “Lesson Study values professional teaching communities and provides an important learning structure—the research lesson. In Lesson study teams, the research lesson provides an ongoing method to improve instruction, ‘ensuring that good ideas are not just talked about but brought to life for shared observation and analysis.’ (Catherine Lewis, 2011).”

This is beautiful, Marilyn. I just ordered the book. Thank you for sharing it. I’m wondering what question might encourage kids to make conjectures within this context? I’m thinking about things like, “If there are an odd number of feet, there has to be a snail.” Where could that kind of thinking go?

The conjecture about a snail (or an odd number of snails) being necessary for an odd number of feet is a terrific idea.

For a group new to this book – who hasn’t yet thought of another way to make 5 feet, etc. – one thought would be to set up a little debate by asking students whether they agree, somewhat agree, or disagree: “If there are 4 feet, there can’t be any snails.” Then we could work our way towards what happens when we have even and odd numbers of snails.

At first I was wondering how the book might be different if there were animals with 3 legs (apparently not found in nature! https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tripedalism) or 5 legs (seastar-that one I know), and so on. As I’ve thought about it more, though, having that singular odd number seems pretty powerful. The snail is the hero of this book! And one is an awfully important number!

I’d like to ask kids, “using just the animals in this book, is there an impossible number of feet to make?”

I’m expecting my copy any day and look forward to playing with it at home with my own kids!

We were not familiar with this book until I read your previous post. Our K-5 Math Coaches also saw ways this piece of literature could be used to support K – 5 math content and ordered a copy for over 1300 teachers. Over 39,000 students in Long Beach Unified School District will be enjoying this book thanks to you!

Your comment makes my heart sing.

Mary Hynes Berry introduced this book to Erikson Institute’s Preschool cohort! I love how she inspired ‘what comes next’ thinking that we could use with preschoolers by pausing and asking the students what they thought would come next in the book! Thank you, Marilyn for your encouragement. I have used this book to inspire Kinders as well. I LOVE MATH thru literature!

Now, I am thinking hard about your suggestion to read thru first. I find this so difficult. I want to ‘talk and discuss’ too soon…. perhaps losing the rhythm and thread of the story. THanks Marilyn!

Mrs. Burns,

I am so glad I found your blog and this book!!! I am loving how this book will spark some excellent algebra conversations in many classrooms. Unfortunately, the link for the graphics is currently not working. Do you have another link?

Thanks!

Thank you Marilyn. I have used this book many times and recommended it even more times. However, there is always more to learn and I found new ideas in your post.

I absolutely love this book! I’ve had kindergarten students demonstrate how to make 10 in as many ways as possible. Some students came up with more than 4 ways in less than 5 minutes! We then worked as a class to demonstrate numbers 1-20 using animal legs. Students were ultra engaged the entire time. Lots of fun and lots of learning!